Skip to main content

Outrageous, Fascistic Repression at Columbia—Four Students Suspended, Evicted from Their Housing! 

Their “Crime”? Being Part of a Program Discussing Palestine

Columbia University student rally to protest raid of Al Shifa Hospital, Gaza, April 4, 2024.

 

Students rally on the Columbia University campus to protest raid of Al Shifa Hospital in Gaza. April 4, 2024.    Screen shot from SJP video

“I did not become a university president to punish students.” 

— Minouche Shafik, President of Columbia University

Really, Ms. Shafik?!? Just since October, to refresh your memory, here’s some of what you’ve done:

  • suspended Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace chapters
  • banned protests not approved by the University administration1 
  • imposed new restrictions on social media and other communications2 
  • refused to come out forcefully against a “skunk chemical spray” attack which sickened pro-Palestinian protesters
  • told students at a Listening Forum that saying “intifada” (uprising) is equivalent to using the N-word. 

Now Columbia University has taken its reactionary campaign of political suppression of those students and faculty standing with the Palestinian people in opposition to Israel’s genocide in Gaza to a whole new, fascistic level.3 

On April 3, the University announced that it was suspending four students, banning them from campus, and evicting them from their University housing—with only 24 hours to clear out!

Their “crime”? They’d allegedly been part of a March 28 “Resistance 101” program on the situation in Gaza that the University hadn’t approved, a program which included a speaker who the university alleges is a member of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. (The speaker denies any affiliation with PFLP.)

Headline from Columbia University Spectator: 4 students suspended following "Resistance 101" support for Palestine event.

 

Screen grab of Columbia Spectator headline

Why should students even have to get permission to have a political discussion—especially at a moment when anyone with an ounce of humanity is duty-bound to act and speak out against the mass murder, torture, blatant war crimes and crimes against humanity and outright genocide Israel is carrying out in Gaza? 

These students should be applauded and celebrated for their courage and convictions. Instead, Columbia University treats them as criminals, hiring a firm led by “former law enforcement investigators”—i.e., pigs—to go after them. Then Columbia charged them (preliminarily) with “disruptive behavior, endangerment, violation of law, violation of University policy, and ‘failure to comply,’” according to the Columbia Spectator. “You may remain in your Columbia residence for 24 hours after which time your access to your residence and dining services will also be suspended,” the students were told.

“Columbia is making us homeless, taking away our campus jobs, our sole source of income, taking away our scholarships, our access to dining halls, our access to classrooms and education that we have earned,” one of the evicted students said at a rally on campus on Thursday, April 4. 

Another targeted student said, “I stand before you today as one of the six Columbia students unjustly and inhumanely suspended from Columbia as of 8 p.m. last night… I received 24-hour notice that I, a full-scholarship, federal-work-study receiving student with disabilities and housing accommodation, will be evicted from my University housing. This was all done with no hearing and no semblance of due process. Shame on Columbia.”

Who Are the World’s #1 Terrorists?

The University cited the U.S. government’s designation of the PFLP (Popular Front for Liberation of Palestine) as a “terrorist” organization as a key reason for going after participants in “Resistance 101.” But why should the U.S. government be able to dictate – or University administrations for that matter—which political forces students can and can’t hear and evaluate for themselves—or what students and faculty can say? Think about the precedent that would set.

By any reasonable definition, including the targeting of civilian non-combatants for political purposes, the U.S. government is the largest “terrorist organization” on the face of the earth. 

To take but one of many examples that could be cited, America’s 2001-2013 “war on terror” contributed to the deaths of some 4.5 million people across seven different countries!4  And right now, the U.S. is enabling its close ally and client Israel to carry out mass murder and to terrorize 2.3 million Palestinians in Gaza and millions more in the occupied West Bank.  

In fact, Columbia University regularly hosts—and honors—leading imperialist and Zionist political figures who have directly helped carry out these bloody crimes. Why, it even has one on its faculty—Hillary Clinton—who, as U.S. Secretary of State in 2011, spearheaded an illegitimate military assault and coup that devastated Libya. She literally burst into laughter at hearing the news of the rape and lynching of Libya’s ousted leader, Muammar Qaddafi.5   

Going After Students for April 4 “All Out for Al-Shifa” Solidarity Protest 

Columbia University Al Shifa rally, April 4, 2024. Credit: Instagram SJP.Columbia

No sooner had students been punished for their “Resistance 101” discussion than the University President, Shafik, announced on April 5 that the University was “in the process of identifying participants” in the April 4 “All Out for Al-Shifa” (the hospital under bombardment by Israel) solidarity protest.6 This was a courageous protest to stop an act of genocide in defiance of Columbia’s illegitimate bans on unauthorized protests.

Shafik warned that identified students “will face discipline under our policies” in a written statement, which illustrated how Columbia as an institution and its leadership are willing cogs in this U.S. imperialist death machine. In condemning recent unauthorized programs and protests, Shafik declared, “I want to make clear that it is absolutely unacceptable for any member of this community to promote the use of terror or violence.”7 Yet Shafik has refused to condemn—or even acknowledge—Israel’s wanton violence in Gaza! She wrote, “I realize that our campus has been deeply shaken by the war between Israel and Hamas, starting Oct. 7 with the horrific Hamas terrorist attack in Israel, and now unfolding as a humanitarian crisis in Gaza.” 

Think about that sentence. What Hamas did was “horrific,” but Israel’s deliberate killing of more than 32,000 Palestinians, overwhelmingly civilians, and its genocidal destruction of the homes, medical and food infrastructure of Gaza is euphemized as a “humanitarian crisis” for which she blames no one. 

What Rules Columbia? The Strategic Interests of U.S. Imperialism

Columbia University claims to uphold free speech, academic freedom, critical thinking and debate—including of unpopular ideas, which it calls a “vital interest” in its 2019 Rules of University Conduct

…fostering a climate in which nothing is immune from scrutiny. And Columbia, in particular, has a long tradition of valuing dissent and controversy and in welcoming the clash of opinions onto the campus. To be true to these principles, the University cannot and will not rule any subject or form of expression out of order on the ground that it is objectionable, offensive, immoral, or untrue.

All this goes out the window when U.S. imperialism’s strategic interests are at stake—and they’re definitely at stake when it comes to Israel and its role as a key pillar of U.S. power, especially at this moment of rising regional and global challenges to its domination of the Middle East. There may be a “Palestine exception” when it comes to speech and activism, but there’s no “exception” to U.S. imperialism fighting to maintain its position as dominant exploiter and oppressor in the world—even if it means arming a massive genocide in Gaza and attempting to stomp out opposition to it.

As the revolutionary leader Bob Avakian highlights in his social media dispatch Revolution #17:

...there is the vicious repression being brought down against people protesting the genocide in Palestine carried out by Israel, with the full backing of the U.S. government and both ruling class political parties (Democrat and Republican). Colleges, and especially "elite" universities, have been a focus of this repression—repression which has crudely violated supposed "rights of free speech" and "standards of academic freedom." Students and faculty have been targeted, and even university presidents have been driven out of their positions for failing to fully repress these protests.

Chilling Impact Even for Tenured Faculty

At a recent discussion of the Al Jazeera documentary The Palestine Exception, Columbia faculty members talked of how this climate of repression was impacting the faculty and the broader dangers it posed:

One anonymous faculty member said that they cannot say stop the violence in Gaza because “there’s no way that that would go well in my department.”

“I know of two instances where faculty members have bullied or tried to use institutional processes to bring consequences against other colleagues whose speech about Palestine and Israel that they don’t like,” [Prof. Joseph] Howley said.

“I think we realized that we are in great danger of losing not only free speech, but academic freedom,” [Prof. Rashid] Khalidi said.8 

“Is This the End of Academic Freedom?”

This was the title of a New York Times opinion piece9 from two New York University professors who expressed similar fears, warning “we are in a moment of unparalleled repression,” in which university administrations aren’t protecting dissent, they’re suppressing it. They write, 

At universities across the country, any criticism of Israel’s policies, expressions of solidarity with Palestinians, organized calls for a ceasefire or even pedagogy on the recent history of the land have all emerged as perilous speech. In a letter to university presidents in November, the A.C.L.U. expressed concern about “impermissible chilling of free speech and association on campus” in relation to pro-Palestinian student groups and views; since then, the atmosphere at colleges has become downright McCarthyite.10 

They warn, 

It is no wonder that students across the country are protesting an unpopular and brutal war that, besides Israel, only the United States is capable of stopping. It is extraordinary that the very institutions that ought to safeguard their exercise of free speech are instead escalating surveillance and policing, working on ever more restrictive student conduct rules and essentially risking the death of academic freedom.

From the Vietnam War to apartheid South Africa, universities have been important places for open discussion and disagreement about government policies, the historical record, structural racism and settler colonialism. They have also long served as sites of protest. If the university cannot serve as an arena for such freedoms, the possibilities of democratic life inside and outside the university gates are not only impoverished but under threat of extinction.

Why Is All This Happening?

As we wrote last week: 

Here, all those courageously standing up need to understand the very real power and significance of their actions—in the fight to stop this genocide, and what this could mean in the fight to overthrow the whole capitalist-imperialist system that is enforcing this genocide. To quote again from Bob Avakian

...representatives of the ruling class in this country have a definite sense that if youth especially at “elite” universities begin to seriously question and act against what this system is doing—if the system “loses the allegiance” of large numbers of those students—that can be a big factor in creating a real crisis for the system as a whole, as happened in the 1960s: a crisis that, now more than ever, this system really cannot afford, when the whole country is already being torn apart by deep divisions, with bitter clashes right among the ruling powers. So, at the same time as they are bitterly divided, the ruling powers of this country are firmly united in their determination to punish and intimidate especially students at elite universities who have stepped forward to protest the genocidal slaughter of Palestinians. The ruling class is desperate to prevent opposition to its fundamental interests from spreading and involving masses of people, from all parts of society.

REVOLUTION 17: 
American Exceptionalism:  further exposing the reality behind the myth

_______________

FOOTNOTES:

1. Columbia released its revised interim demonstration policy on February 19, restricting protests to the South Lawn and Sundial from noon to 6 pm on weekdays and prohibiting student groups and their individual members from advertising demonstrations before they are approved. Columbia establishes ‘Demonstration Areas’ and times, alters disciplinary procedure for students in violation of new event policy, Columbia Spectator, February 19, 2024. [back]

2. University releases new social media guidelines, bans certain content in its comment sections, Columbia Spectator, February 20, 2024. [back]

3. Four Columbia students suspended, evicted from University housing following unauthorized ‘Resistance 101’ event, Columbia Spectator, April 4, 2024. [back]

4. Post-9/11 wars have contributed to some 4.5 million deaths, report suggests,” Washington Post, May 15, 2023. For an overall picture, see the American Crime series at revcom.us. [back]

5. American Crime Case #35: The 2011 U.S.-NATO War on Libya, revcom.us, September 18, 2023. [back]

6. Shafik confirms suspensions following ‘Resistance 101’ event as Columbia works to identify protest participants, Columbia Spectator, April 5, 2024. [back]

7. To be clear, pro-Palestine protesters at Columbia have staged political protests. They have not carried out acts of terror or violence. [back]

8. Students, faculty host Al Jazeera documentary screening and panel for ‘The Palestine Exception,’ Columbia Spectator, April 4, 2024. [back]

9. At NYU, they write,

“About a week after Hamas’s attacks in October, the Grand Staircase in the Kimmel student center, a storied site of student protests, closed indefinitely; it has yet to reopen fully. A graduate student employee was reprimanded for putting up fliers in support of Palestinians on the student’s office door and ultimately took them down; the person is not the only N.Y.U. student to face some form of disciplinary consequence for pro-Palestinian speech or action. A resolution calling for the university to reaffirm protection of pro-Palestinian speech and civic activity on campus, passed by the elected Student Government Assembly back in December, has apparently been stuck in a procedural black hole since. The New York Police Department has become a pervasive presence on campus, with over 6,000 hours of officer presence added after the war broke out. Hundreds of faculty members have signed onto an open letter condemning the university’s ‘culture of fear about campus speech and activism.’” [back]

10. Is This the End of Academic Freedom? New York Times, April 5, 2024. [back]

We are at a turning point in history. The capitalist-imperialist system is a horror for billions of people here and around the world and threatening the very fabric of life on earth. Now the election of fascist Trump poses even more extreme dangers for humanity—and underscores the total illegitimacy of this system, and the urgent need for a radically different system.

The website Revcom.us follows the revolutionary leadership of Bob Avakian (BA), the author of the new communism. Bob Avakian has scientifically analyzed that we are in a rare time when an actual revolution has become more possible in the U.S. He’s charted a strategy for making that revolution, and laid out a sweeping vision and concrete blueprint for “what comes next” in the Constitution for the New Socialist Republic in North America.

Revcom.us projects BA’s voice, leadership, and vision throughout society. It posts his timely leadership for the revcoms (revolutionary communists) and the whole movement for revolution, including his social media posts, and curates his whole body of work. 

Our website applies the scientific approach BA has developed to analyze major events in society and the world—why they are happening, how they relate to each other, how all this relates to the system we live under, where people's interests lie, how revolution is in fact the solution to all this, and what the goals of that revolution are.

Revcom.us acts as a guiding and connecting hub for the revcom movement nationwide: showing what’s being done, digging into what’s right and what’s wrong, and rapidly learning—and recruiting new people into what has to be a rapidly growing force. As part of this, revcom.us feature and promotes the weekly The RNL—Revolution, Nothing Less!—Show on YouTube.com. 

Put it this way: there will be no revolution unless this website not only “keeps going” but rises to a whole different level!

DONATE NOW to revcom.us and get with BA and the revcoms!

Your donations contribute to:

If you are horrified at the Trump/MAGA fascism spawned by this system of capitalism-imperialism coming to power in the world’s top nuclear-armed superpower… outraged at the tremendous harm this fascism is perpetrating on people in this country and the whole world… hate the Dark Ages morality and Christian fascism that they are trying to forcibly impose…see the very existence of humanity being threatened by the increasing danger of nuclear war and destruction of the environment: Be part of supporting this revcom.us website that—now more than ever—plays a crucial role in exposing the system ruling over us and in leading people out of this madness to a radically different and far better future. 

See FIVE REASONS you should donate, spread the word about revcom.us, and urge your friends and others to donate and subscribe to this website.